Why Do Contractors Prefer Steel Studs Over Wooden Ones?

Home Improvement

Steel vs. Wood

Steel studs have their own set of advantages and disadvantages.
iStockphoto/Thinkstock

Despite their benefits, steel studs are not as strong as wooden ones, especially the lighter versions that are only suitable for interior, non-load-bearing walls. Some contractors caution against using steel studs for hanging heavy objects like kitchen cabinets. Additionally, steel studs can be more expensive than wooden ones, and there are special considerations when framing with metal, such as using different cables and electrical boxes to avoid electrical conductivity.

While steel is recyclable and therefore considered more environmentally friendly than wood, producing steel generates pollution from mining the ore and recycling the metal. Moreover, steel conducts cold, and a specific type of insulation made of extruded polystyrene must be used to create a strong, thermal barrier for a building with metal framing. This can lead to a more energy-efficient house, though.

In very cold and humid areas, condensation can form on steel studs, which can rust and require moisture-proof barriers. It is also more difficult for DIY enthusiasts to work with steel studs as they are harder to cut and screw drywall into. Heavy-duty steel studs, which are the only type suitable for outside or load-bearing walls, may not be available at local home improvement stores and may need to be sourced from contractors’ suppliers.

Ultimately, the choice between steel and wooden studs depends on personal preference. While steel may be preferred for some applications, wood is still necessary for trim, window and door framing, and bathrooms due to plumbing requirements.

FAQ

1. What are steel studs?

Steel studs are framing members used in construction to create interior walls and ceilings. They are made of steel and come in various sizes and shapes.

2. How do steel studs compare to wood studs?

Steel studs are stronger than wood studs and are less susceptible to warping, twisting, and shrinking. They are also fire-resistant and do not attract pests like termites. However, they are more expensive than wood studs.

3. Why are steel studs more common than wood?

Steel studs are more commonly used than wood studs in commercial construction because of their strength and durability. They are also easier to work with and install because they are uniform in size and shape.

4. Are steel studs environmentally friendly?

Steel studs are not as environmentally friendly as wood studs because they require more energy to produce and are not biodegradable. However, they are recyclable and can be reused in other construction projects.

5. Can steel studs be used in residential construction?

Yes, steel studs can be used in residential construction. They are more commonly used in high-rise buildings and commercial structures, but they can be used in residential homes as well.

6. Are steel studs more expensive than wood studs?

Yes, steel studs are more expensive than wood studs. However, the cost difference is offset by their durability and strength, which can save money in the long run.

7. Can steel studs be used for exterior walls?

Steel studs can be used for exterior walls, but they must be properly insulated to prevent heat loss and condensation. Wood studs are more commonly used for exterior walls in residential construction.

8. Do steel studs require special tools to install?

Steel studs require special tools to install, such as metal cutting saws, metal drill bits, and metal screws. However, these tools are readily available at most hardware stores.

9. How long do steel studs last?

Steel studs can last for decades without deteriorating or losing strength. They are a durable and long-lasting option for construction projects.

10. Are steel studs fire-resistant?

Yes, steel studs are fire-resistant and can help prevent the spread of fire in a building. This is a major advantage over wood studs, which are highly combustible.